Crypto Token Legal Opinion Guidance

a22162
7 hours ago
7 min read

Hong Kong Crypto Token Legal Opinion Guidance

In Hong Kong, the regulatory landscape for crypto tokens is constantly evolving, with the Securities and Futures Commission (SFC) and the Hong Kong Monetary Authority (HKMA) playing key roles. Obtaining a legal opinion is often a critical step for projects involving crypto tokens, particularly when seeking to operate in or offer services to Hong Kong.

Here's a breakdown of the key aspects and guidance related to crypto token legal opinions in Hong Kong:

1. Classification of Crypto Tokens is Paramount:

The SFC's primary approach is to determine if a crypto token falls under the definition of "securities" or "futures contracts" under the Securities and Futures Ordinance (SFO). This classification is crucial because it dictates the applicable regulatory regime.

Security Tokens: If a crypto token possesses characteristics of a security (e.g., representing ownership in a company, a right to profit-sharing, or an investment return derived from third-party efforts), it will be subject to the SFO and regulated by the SFC. Activities related to security tokens, such as dealing in or advising on them, may require relevant licenses.
Non-Security Tokens (e.g., Utility Tokens, Pure Cryptocurrencies like Bitcoin/Ethereum): While not inherently regulated under the SFO, their trading platforms have been brought under a mandatory licensing regime. Since June 1, 2023, centralized Virtual Asset Trading Platforms (VATPs) operating in or actively marketing to Hong Kong must obtain a license from the SFC, even if they only list non-security tokens.
Stablecoins: Hong Kong is finalizing a bespoke regulatory regime for fiat-backed stablecoins, requiring issuers to obtain a license from the HKMA and maintain one-to-one reserves, undergo audits, and ensure transparency.
Virtual Assets (VA): The Anti-Money Laundering and Counter-Terrorist Financing Ordinance (AMLO) defines "virtual assets" broadly as digital representations of value used as a medium of exchange, store of economic value, or providing voting rights in cryptographically secured digital representations of value.

2. When is a Legal Opinion Typically Required?

A legal opinion is a statement from a qualified lawyer assessing the legal nature of a token based on applicable laws and regulations. It is highly recommended and often mandatory in several scenarios:

Listing on Regulated Centralized Exchanges (CEXs): Most regulated CEXs will require a legal opinion to confirm the token's classification and compliance status before listing.
Opening Crypto Bank Accounts: Banks often demand a legal opinion to confirm the legality of crypto-related operations.
Initial Token Offerings (ITOs/ICOs/STOs): To assess whether the token constitutes a security and to ensure compliance with relevant regulations and avoid potential lawsuits.
Engaging in Regulated Activities: If your project involves activities like operating a virtual asset trading platform, providing virtual asset dealing or advisory services, or managing virtual asset funds, a legal opinion is essential to determine licensing requirements and ensure compliance with the SFC's framework.
Fund Structuring: For crypto-focused funds, legal opinions are vital for structuring them in a tax-efficient and compliant manner.
AML/CTF Compliance: To ensure that the token and related activities comply with Hong Kong's robust Anti-Money Laundering (AML) and Counter-Terrorist Financing (CTF) requirements.
Regulatory Scrutiny: If regulatory authorities raise doubts about a token's nature or a project's compliance, a legal opinion can serve as a defense and clarify the legal position.

3. Key Considerations for a Hong Kong Crypto Legal Opinion:

A comprehensive legal opinion for crypto tokens in Hong Kong should typically address:

Token Classification: A thorough analysis of the token's features, rights, and utility to determine its classification under Hong Kong law (e.g., security, utility, commodity, or a hybrid).
Applicable Regulatory Regimes: Identifying which Hong Kong laws and regulations apply to the token and the activities associated with it (e.g., SFO, AMLO, Payment Systems and Stored Value Facilities Ordinance (PSSVFO) for stablecoins).
Licensing Requirements: Determining if any licenses from the SFC, HKMA, or other authorities are required for issuing, trading, or dealing with the token, or for operating a platform that facilitates these activities.
Investor Protection: Assessment of how investor protection measures apply, especially for retail investors. Hong Kong has a strong focus on investor safeguards, including strict custody requirements for licensed VASPs.
AML/CTF Compliance: Detailing the necessary Know Your Customer (KYC) and AML protocols that must be in place.
Tax Implications: While Hong Kong generally has no capital gains tax on crypto trading, a legal opinion may touch upon corporate tax, income tax, and other relevant tax considerations.
Marketing and Promotion: Guidance on how the token can be legally marketed and promoted in Hong Kong.
Cross-Border Implications: If the token or project has international aspects, the legal opinion should consider how Hong Kong law interacts with other relevant jurisdictions.
Ongoing Compliance Obligations: Outlining continuous compliance requirements for the project.

4. SFC's Regulatory Roadmap and Future Trends:

The SFC continues to refine its regulatory approach. Its "ASPIRe" framework (Access, Safeguards, Products, Infrastructure, and Relationships) released in February 2025 outlines its strategic plan for the virtual asset market, indicating:

Streamlined Market Entry: Clearer licensing frameworks.
Optimized Compliance: Flexible and outcome-driven regulatory approach, possibly moving towards technology-neutral custody standards.
Expanded Product Offerings: Considering allowing more diverse product offerings for investors with sufficient expertise.
Enhanced Infrastructure: Modernizing reporting and surveillance tools.
Global Harmonization: Alignment with international standards set by FATF, IOSCO, and FSB.

5. Engaging Legal Counsel:

Given the complexity and dynamic nature of crypto regulations in Hong Kong, it is crucial to engage experienced legal counsel specializing in fintech, blockchain, and virtual assets. They can provide tailored advice, conduct the necessary legal analysis, and issue comprehensive legal opinions to help navigate the regulatory landscape effectively.

By obtaining a well-reasoned legal opinion, crypto projects can demonstrate their commitment to compliance, mitigate legal risks, and build trust with regulators, investors, and business partners in Hong Kong.

How Bestar can Help

Bestar, as a professional services firm, can be a valuable partner for crypto and blockchain companies navigating the complex Hong Kong regulatory landscape. While we may not directly issue legal opinions overselves (as that typically requires a law firm), our services can significantly facilitate the process and provide comprehensive support.

Here's how Bestar can help in relation to crypto token legal opinions and broader crypto operations:

1. Facilitating Legal Opinion Procurement (Through Partnered Lawyers):

Connecting with Legal Experts: Bestar often partners with experienced lawyers and law firms specializing in fintech, blockchain, and virtual asset regulation in Hong Kong. We can leverage these connections to introduce you to qualified legal professionals who can issue the necessary legal opinion for your crypto token.
Information Gathering and Preparation: Bestar can assist in compiling the crucial information and documentation required by the lawyers to form their legal opinion. This includes details about the token's features, utility, underlying technology, business model, target market, and operational flows. Our expertise in corporate secretarial and financial services can streamline this data collection.
Liaison and Coordination: Bestar can act as a central point of contact between your project and the legal team, ensuring smooth communication and efficient information exchange throughout the legal opinion process.

2. Company Formation and Structuring for Crypto Businesses:

Company Registration: We can handle the full process of incorporating a company in Hong Kong, which is often the foundational step for any crypto venture looking to operate legally. This includes choosing the right legal entity (e.g., private limited company), name registration, and preparing necessary documents like the Memorandum and Articles of Association.
Strategic Structuring: Bestar can advise on the most suitable company structure for your crypto business, considering factors like regulatory compliance, tax efficiency, and operational needs. This is crucial for navigating Hong Kong's nuanced approach to virtual assets.
Registered Office and Company Secretary: We provide essential corporate secretarial services, including acting as your company secretary and providing a registered office address, both of which are mandatory for Hong Kong companies.

3. Regulatory Compliance Support:

Understanding Licensing Requirements: Bestar can provide guidance on whether your crypto activities require specific licenses from the SFC (for Virtual Asset Trading Platforms, fund managers, etc.) or the HKMA (for stablecoin issuers). We can help you understand the criteria.
AML/CTF Compliance: We can assist in understanding and implementing robust Anti-Money Laundering (AML) and Counter-Terrorist Financing (CTF) protocols, which are paramount for any crypto business operating in Hong Kong. This includes advising on KYC procedures and suspicious activity reporting.
Ongoing Compliance: Bestar can help ensure your company adheres to ongoing regulatory obligations, including financial reporting, record-keeping, and corporate governance best practices.

4. Financial and Advisory Services for Crypto Projects:

Bookkeeping and Accounting: We offer comprehensive bookkeeping and accounting services, ensuring accurate financial records that are essential for regulatory compliance and audits.
Tax Advisory: Bestar can advise on the tax implications of your crypto operations in Hong Kong, including corporate tax and the absence of capital gains tax on crypto trading for most entities.
Financial Advisory: We can offer broader financial advisory services, which might be relevant for fundraising, business planning, and risk management in the context of a crypto project.

5. Other Related Support:

Due Diligence: Bestar can conduct due diligence, which may be required for partnerships, investments, or during the licensing process.
HR Consulting and Payroll: For growing crypto companies, we can assist with employment pass applications, payroll outsourcing, and general HR consulting.

In summary:

While Bestar itself is not a law firm that issues legal opinions, we serve as a comprehensive business service provider. Our strength lies in providing the foundational corporate, financial, and compliance support that is prerequisite to obtaining a legal opinion and successfully operating a crypto business in Hong Kong. We can effectively bridge the gap between your project's technical and business aspects and the specialized legal expertise required for regulatory navigation in the crypto space.

If you are looking to obtain a legal opinion for your crypto token in Hong Kong, contacting Bestar would be a good first step. We can assess your needs and connect you with our network of legal partners while handling the various corporate and compliance aspects of your operation.

Request for Proposal