HK-Indonesia Tax Treaty Advice

HK-Indonesia Tax Treaty Advice | Bestar

HK-Indonesia Tax Treaty Advice Summary

The Double Taxation Agreement (DTA) between Hong Kong and Indonesia is a significant agreement designed to prevent double taxation and promote investment and trade between the two jurisdictions. It entered into force in March 2012 and became effective in Hong Kong from April 1, 2013.

Here's a summary of key aspects and benefits of the HK-Indonesia Tax Treaty:

1. Reduced Withholding Tax (WHT) Rates:

• Dividends:

  
  

  • The treaty generally provides a 10% WHT rate on dividends paid from Indonesia to Hong Kong residents.

  • This rate is further reduced to 5% if the beneficial owner is a company directly holding at least 25% of the capital of the Indonesian company paying the dividends. This is a particularly favorable rate compared to Indonesia's treaties with other jurisdictions like Singapore and the Netherlands (which often have a 10% rate).

    
    

• Interest: The WHT rate on interest payments from Indonesia to Hong Kong residents is generally capped at 10%. However, certain Hong Kong institutions (like the Government of HKSAR, HKMA, or statutory bodies) may enjoy a 0% interest rate on income.

  
  

• Royalties: The WHT rate on royalties paid from Indonesia to Hong Kong residents is capped at 5%, a significant reduction from the non-treaty rate of 20%.

2. Capital Gains:

• Generally, capital gains arising from the alienation of shares in a non-land-rich Indonesian company by a Hong Kong resident are taxable only in Hong Kong. Since Hong Kong does not impose capital gains tax, this can result in a tax exemption on such gains.

  
  

• However, specific rules apply to capital gains from the alienation of shares of a company whose assets consist directly or indirectly principally of immovable property.

3. Permanent Establishment (PE):

• The treaty defines what constitutes a "permanent establishment," which determines when a company's profits in one jurisdiction can be taxed in the other.

  
  

• It includes a service PE clause, meaning that services provided by an enterprise in the other contracting state can create a PE if they continue for a period of at least 183 days within any 12-month period.

  
  

4. Shipping and Air Transport:

• Profits from the operation of ships or aircraft in international traffic are generally taxable only in the contracting party where the effective management of the enterprise is situated.

5. Prevention of Fiscal Evasion:

• The DTA also includes provisions for the exchange of information between the tax authorities of Hong Kong and Indonesia to prevent fiscal evasion.

Important Considerations and Advice:

• Substance Requirements: To benefit from the reduced WHT rates and other advantages of the treaty, it is crucial for Hong Kong companies investing in Indonesia to demonstrate genuine economic and physical substance in Hong Kong. Indonesian tax authorities are increasingly scrutinizing "treaty shopping" arrangements. This means having:

  
  

  • Sufficient employees with relevant expertise.

  • Genuine business activities beyond merely receiving passive income.

  • Adequate fixed and non-fixed assets.

  • Control over the assets generating the income.

  • No obligation to transfer the income to residents of a third country (Beneficial Ownership test).

    
    

• Certificate of Domicile (CoD): To claim treaty benefits in Indonesia, the Hong Kong resident must present a Certificate of Domicile (or Certificate of Resident Status) to the Indonesian tax authorities.

  
  

• Specific Advice: Tax treaties are complex, and their application can depend on the specific facts and circumstances of each case. It is highly recommended to seek professional tax advice from a qualified tax consultant or lawyer specializing in international tax for specific situations involving investments or activities between Hong Kong and Indonesia. They can help you understand the nuances of the treaty, ensure compliance with substance requirements, and optimize your tax position.

  
  

• Ongoing Developments: Tax laws and treaties can be amended or reinterpreted. It's important to stay updated on any changes to the HK-Indonesia DTA or domestic tax regulations in either jurisdiction.

In essence, the HK-Indonesia DTA offers significant tax advantages for businesses and individuals engaged in cross-border activities, particularly in terms of reduced withholding taxes on dividends, interest, and royalties, and beneficial treatment of capital gains. However, proper structuring and adherence to substance requirements are critical to realizing these benefits.

How Bestar can Help

HK-Indonesia Tax Treaty Advice

Bestar plays a crucial role in helping individuals and businesses navigate the complexities of double taxation agreements (DTAs) like the one between Hong Kong and Indonesia. Here's a breakdown of how we can assist:

1. Strategic Tax Planning and Structuring:

• Understanding the Treaty's Nuances: We possess in-depth knowledge of the DTA's specific articles, clauses, and interpretations. We can explain how the reduced withholding tax rates on dividends, interest, and royalties apply to your specific situation and if you meet the eligibility criteria (e.g., beneficial ownership, shareholding thresholds).

  
  

• Optimizing Business Structures: We can advise on the most tax-efficient corporate structures for cross-border investments and operations between Hong Kong and Indonesia. This might involve setting up holding companies, special purpose vehicles, or branches in a way that maximizes treaty benefits while complying with both jurisdictions' tax laws.

  
  

• Profit Repatriation Strategies: We can help devise strategies for repatriating profits from Indonesia to Hong Kong in a tax-efficient manner, considering withholding tax rates and other relevant provisions.

  
  

• Capital Gains Planning: We can advise on the tax implications of capital gains from the sale of assets (e.g., shares in Indonesian companies) and help structure transactions to minimize or eliminate tax liabilities, particularly given Hong Kong's general absence of capital gains tax.

  
  

• Transfer Pricing: For related-party transactions (e.g., sales of goods, provision of services, or licensing of intellectual property between a Hong Kong parent and Indonesian subsidiary), we can help ensure compliance with transfer pricing rules and the "arm's length principle" as mandated by the DTA and OECD guidelines. This includes preparing necessary documentation and potentially negotiating Advance Pricing Agreements (APAs) with tax authorities for certainty.

2. Ensuring Compliance and Mitigating Risks:

• Substance Requirements: This is a critical area. Bestar will emphasize the importance of demonstrating "substance" in Hong Kong to avoid being challenged by Indonesian tax authorities for "treaty shopping." We can advise on what constitutes sufficient substance (e.g., real business activities, employees, physical presence, decision-making processes) to support a claim for treaty benefits.

  
  

• Certificate of Domicile (CoD) / Resident Status: We can assist in obtaining the necessary Certificate of Domicile from the Hong Kong Inland Revenue Department (IRD) and guide you through the process of submitting it to the Indonesian tax authorities to claim treaty benefits.

  
  

• Permanent Establishment (PE) Risk Assessment: We can assess whether your activities in Indonesia could create a "permanent establishment," which would trigger Indonesian corporate income tax obligations. We can advise on how to structure operations to avoid unintended PE creation or manage the tax implications if a PE is unavoidable.

  
  

• Tax Due Diligence: During mergers, acquisitions, or other significant transactions, we can conduct tax due diligence to identify potential tax risks and liabilities associated with the target entity or transaction structure.

  
  

• FATCA/CRS Compliance: They can provide guidance on compliance with international information exchange regimes like FATCA and CRS, ensuring that your financial institutions and accounts are properly reported.

3. Dispute Resolution and Representation:

• Tax Audits and Investigations: If the Indonesian tax authorities challenge your claim for treaty benefits or initiate an audit, Bestar can represent you, prepare responses, and negotiate on your behalf.

  
  

• Mutual Agreement Procedure (MAP): If double taxation still occurs despite applying the DTA, we can assist in initiating a Mutual Agreement Procedure (MAP) with the competent authorities of Hong Kong and Indonesia to resolve the dispute and ensure that income is taxed in accordance with the treaty.

  
  

• Tax Appeals and Litigation: In more severe cases, we can represent you in tax appeals or litigation before tax tribunals or courts in either jurisdiction.

4. Keeping Up-to-Date:

• Tax laws and treaty interpretations can change. Bestar stays abreast of the latest developments, including OECD initiatives (like BEPS - Base Erosion and Profit Shifting), and their impact on the DTA and your tax position. We can proactively advise on necessary adjustments to your structure or operations.

In essence, Bestar provides specialized expertise that can save you significant time, money, and potential legal headaches. We help you navigate the complex international tax landscape, ensure compliance, mitigate risks, and ultimately optimize your tax position when dealing with cross-border activities between Hong Kong and Indonesia.

Request for Proposal